(616) 335-0939 gavinmirealtor@gmail.com Indigo Key Realty
Traffic Dashboard
Home
  • Search
  • Communities
    • Allendale
    • Fennville
    • Grandville
    • Grand Haven
    • Grand Rapids
    • Hamilton
    • Holland
    • Hudsonville
    • Jenison
    • Saugatuck
    • South Haven
    • West Olive
    • Zeeland
    • Ottawa County
    • Allegan County
  • Buying
    • Buying Info
    • Featured Listings
    • Search Homes
  • Selling
  • Recently Sold
  • About
    • Meet The Expert
    • Testimonials
  • Articles
  • Contact
Traffic Dashboard
Gavin Steenwyk
(616) 335-0939 gavinmirealtor@gmail.com
About
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
Search
  • Search Properties
Local Guide
  • Search by City
  • Search by Subdivision
  • Search by Zip
  • Search by Area
Legal
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Accessibility
  • Fair Housing
Account
  • Dashboard
  • Logout
  • Login
Gavin Steenwyk - Footer Logo
©2026 Indigo Key Realty. All rights reserved.
Website built by CloseHack.

Michigan Regional Information Center

© MichRIC. All rights reserved. Information Deemed Reliable, but Not Guaranteed. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in IDX and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided is for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Back

Listings in Newaygo, MI

Gavin Steenwyk
Gavin Steenwyk Indigo Key Realty

Get more information about Newaygo

Newaygo Listings Market Stats Subdivisions Zip Codes Neighborhood FAQs Nearby

Houses in Newaygo, MI

homeMore houses
1385 W Shady Drive
$575,000
26053267
For Sale
1385 W Shady Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
5 Beds bathtub 3 Baths straighten 3390 sq ft
4908 Juniper Ridge Avenue
$850,000
26053069
For Sale
4908 Juniper Ridge Avenue Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 2.5 Baths straighten 3660 sq ft
5565 Cozy Point Drive
$324,900
26050735
For Sale
5565 Cozy Point Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 2 Baths straighten 1456 sq ft
2341 E 95th Street
$399,900
26049992
For Sale
2341 E 95th Street Newaygo, MI 49337
4 Beds bathtub 3 Baths straighten 2468 sq ft
39363944 Truesdale Street
$699,900
26049669
For Sale
39363944 Truesdale Street Newaygo, MI 49337
6 Beds bathtub 2 Baths straighten 2100 sq ft
9254 S Redwood Drive
$459,900
26049490
For Sale
9254 S Redwood Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 2 Baths straighten 1436 sq ft
89 E Post Street
$189,900
26049335
For Sale
89 E Post Street Newaygo, MI 49337
4 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 1600 sq ft
7842 Main Street
$475,000
26049118
For Sale
7842 Main Street Newaygo, MI 49337
5 Beds bathtub 2 Baths straighten 2448 sq ft
7603 S Croton Hardy Drive
$541,500
26049104
For Sale
7603 S Croton Hardy Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 2.5 Baths straighten 1900 sq ft
3936 Truesdale Street
$450,000
26049064
For Sale
3936 Truesdale Street Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 1200 sq ft
3944 Truesdale Street
$275,000
26049047
For Sale
3944 Truesdale Street Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 900 sq ft
8 E Barton Street
$215,000
26048343
For Sale
8 E Barton Street Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 1496 sq ft
4629 S Croton Hardy Drive
$229,900
26048193
For Sale
4629 S Croton Hardy Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
1 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 288 sq ft
338 Maple Street
$299,900
26046818
For Sale
338 Maple Street Newaygo, MI 49337
4 Beds bathtub 2 Baths straighten 2212 sq ft
7017 Elm Avenue
$389,000
26046617
For Sale
7017 Elm Avenue Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 2 Baths straighten 2159 sq ft
8794 S Spruce Avenue
$575,900
26045998
For Sale
8794 S Spruce Avenue Newaygo, MI 49337
6 Beds bathtub 4 Baths straighten 4083 sq ft
5540 Cozy Point Drive
$489,900
26045102
For Sale
5540 Cozy Point Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
2 Beds bathtub 1.5 Baths straighten 1352 sq ft
8540 S Vista Drive
$489,900
26044275
For Sale
8540 S Vista Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 2 Baths straighten 2160 sq ft
8221 S Island View Drive
$249,000
26042296
For Sale
8221 S Island View Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
1 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 400 sq ft
8215 S Island View Drive
$485,000
26042290
For Sale
8215 S Island View Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
3 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 1800 sq ft
5708 E 52nd Street
$499,900
26041882
For Sale
5708 E 52nd Street Newaygo, MI 49337
2 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 960 sq ft
8478 Vista Drive
$225,000
26040220
For Sale
8478 Vista Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
2 Beds bathtub 1 Baths straighten 960 sq ft
3810 W 72nd Street
$599,000
26040069
For Sale
3810 W 72nd Street Newaygo, MI 49337
4 Beds bathtub 2.5 Baths straighten 2184 sq ft
5420 S Kathryn Lane
$724,900
26035628
For Sale
5420 S Kathryn Lane Newaygo, MI 49337
5 Beds bathtub 2.5 Baths straighten 2920 sq ft

Lots & Land in Newaygo, MI

crop_landscapeMore land
Carol Street
$34,900
26053145
For Sale
Carol Street Newaygo, MI 49337
23451 Cutler Road
$120,000
26047356
For Sale
23451 Cutler Road Newaygo, MI 49337
9433 S Annie Lane
$62,500
26047114
For Sale
9433 S Annie Lane Newaygo, MI 49337
10381 Woodland Lane
$54,900
26045959
For Sale
10381 Woodland Lane Newaygo, MI 49337
S Deer Point Drive
$399,900
26043046
For Sale
S Deer Point Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
Tamarack Road
$38,000
26039666
For Sale
Tamarack Road Newaygo, MI 49337
7812 Mary Avenue
$59,000
26036951
For Sale
7812 Mary Avenue Newaygo, MI 49337
bathtub 1 Baths
1672 E Croton Drive
$142,000
26032389
For Sale
1672 E Croton Drive Newaygo, MI 49337
866 W 90th Street
$189,999
26027357
For Sale
866 W 90th Street Newaygo, MI 49337
4143 S Pine Avenue
$129,000
26024009
For Sale
4143 S Pine Avenue Newaygo, MI 49337
S Teal Lane
$60,000
26013915
For Sale
S Teal Lane Newaygo, MI 49337
E Woodlawn Avenue
$49,900
26003647
For Sale
E Woodlawn Avenue Newaygo, MI 49337
7901 S Potawatomi #56
$69,500
24024108
For Sale
7901 S Potawatomi #56 Newaygo, MI 49337
7883 S Potawatomi #57
$69,500
24024106
For Sale
7883 S Potawatomi #57 Newaygo, MI 49337
7817 S Potawatomi #60
$69,500
24024101
For Sale
7817 S Potawatomi #60 Newaygo, MI 49337
4987 E Manitou Way #37
$69,500
24024096
For Sale
4987 E Manitou Way #37 Newaygo, MI 49337
5007 E Manitou Way #36
$69,500
24024095
For Sale
5007 E Manitou Way #36 Newaygo, MI 49337

MARKET SNAPSHOT

The Market at a Glance

How homes have been selling here over the last 90 days.

home_work New This Week 4
Went Under Contract 0
trending_down Price Reductions 0
payments Median Sale Price $283,500 -8.5%
square_foot Price per Sq Ft $235
schedule Avg Days on Market 21
sell Homes Sold 30
percent Sale-to-List Ratio 97.0%
inventory_2 Months of Inventory 16.7

Price & Sales History

Market data reflects closed sales over the last 90 days and is provided for informational purposes.

Gavin Steenwyk
Gavin Steenwyk Indigo Key Realty (616) 335-0939 gavinmirealtor@gmail.com

Zip Codes

BROWSE BY ZIP

Browse listings by postal code in this area.

463509 homes for saleMedian sale$270KPer sq ft$170127 sales in the last 90 days
463602 homes for saleMedian sale$289.5KPer sq ft$240100 sales in the last 90 days
480015 homes for saleMedian sale$325KPer sq ft$21393 sales in the last 90 days
480032 homes for saleMedian sale$328.3KPer sq ft$18634 sales in the last 90 days
480051 home for saleMedian sale$400KPer sq ft$22221 sales in the last 90 days
4800912 homes for saleMedian sale$1MPer sq ft$38699 sales in the last 90 days
480141 home for saleMedian sale$299KPer sq ft$1558 sales in the last 90 days
480152 homes for saleMedian sale$184.9KPer sq ft$13224 sales in the last 90 days
480172 homes for saleMedian sale$325KPer sq ft$21055 sales in the last 90 days
4802119 homes for saleMedian sale$164.9KPer sq ft$122133 sales in the last 90 days
480256 homes for saleMedian sale$606KPer sq ft$22798 sales in the last 90 days
480261 home for saleMedian sale$245.3KPer sq ft$15752 sales in the last 90 days
View All Zip Codes
Get Alerts Advanced Search
  • Grid
  • Map
  • List
1385 W Shady Drive
For Sale
$575,000

1385 W Shady Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

5 bd 3 ba 3390 sqft 2002 built
4908 Juniper Ridge Avenue
For Sale
$850,000

4908 Juniper Ridge Avenue

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2.5 ba 3660 sqft 1997 built
5565 Cozy Point Drive
For Sale
$324,900

5565 Cozy Point Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 1456 sqft 1997 built
2341 E 95th Street
For Sale
$399,900

2341 E 95th Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

4 bd 3 ba 2468 sqft 1986 built
39363944 Truesdale Street
For Sale
$699,900

39363944 Truesdale Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

6 bd 2 ba 2100 sqft 1965 built
9254 S Redwood Drive
For Sale
$459,900

9254 S Redwood Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 1436 sqft 1976 built
89 E Post Street
For Sale
$189,900

89 E Post Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

4 bd 1 ba 1600 sqft 1900 built
7842 Main Street
For Sale
$475,000

7842 Main Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

5 bd 2 ba 2448 sqft 1959 built
7603 S Croton Hardy Drive
For Sale
$541,500

7603 S Croton Hardy Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2.5 ba 1900 sqft 2026 built
3936 Truesdale Street
For Sale
$450,000

3936 Truesdale Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 1 ba 1200 sqft 1965 built
3944 Truesdale Street
For Sale
$275,000

3944 Truesdale Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 1 ba 900 sqft 1950 built
8 E Barton Street
For Sale
$215,000

8 E Barton Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 1 ba 1496 sqft 1920 built
4629 S Croton Hardy Drive
For Sale
$229,900

4629 S Croton Hardy Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

1 bd 1 ba 288 sqft 1960 built
338 Maple Street
For Sale
$299,900

338 Maple Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

4 bd 2 ba 2212 sqft 2006 built
7017 Elm Avenue
For Sale
$389,000

7017 Elm Avenue

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 2159 sqft 1993 built
8794 S Spruce Avenue
For Sale
$575,900

8794 S Spruce Avenue

Newaygo, MI 49337

6 bd 4 ba 4083 sqft 2004 built
5540 Cozy Point Drive
For Sale
$489,900

5540 Cozy Point Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

2 bd 1.5 ba 1352 sqft 1972 built
8540 S Vista Drive
For Sale
$489,900

8540 S Vista Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 2160 sqft 1950 built
8221 S Island View Drive
For Sale
$249,000

8221 S Island View Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

1 bd 1 ba 400 sqft 1950 built
8215 S Island View Drive
For Sale
$485,000

8215 S Island View Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 1 ba 1800 sqft 2004 built
5708 E 52nd Street
For Sale
$499,900

5708 E 52nd Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

2 bd 1 ba 960 sqft 1970 built
8478 Vista Drive
For Sale
$225,000

8478 Vista Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

2 bd 1 ba 960 sqft 2026 built
3810 W 72nd Street
For Sale
$599,000

3810 W 72nd Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

4 bd 2.5 ba 2184 sqft
5420 S Kathryn Lane
For Sale
$724,900

5420 S Kathryn Lane

Newaygo, MI 49337

5 bd 2.5 ba 2920 sqft 2017 built
269 W Brooks Street
For Sale
$314,900

269 W Brooks Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 1176 sqft 2022 built
8750 S Spruce Avenue
For Sale
$399,000

8750 S Spruce Avenue

Newaygo, MI 49337

1 bd 1 ba 1200 sqft 1960 built
8188 E Woodruff Drive
For Sale
$249,900

8188 E Woodruff Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 1 ba 1351 sqft 1991 built
5343 S Front Street
For Sale
$319,900

5343 S Front Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

1 bd 1 ba 752 sqft 1940 built
172 Bridge Street
For Sale
$315,000

172 Bridge Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 1095 sqft 1920 built
202 S Clay Street
For Sale
$234,900

202 S Clay Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

2 bd 1 ba 1000 sqft 1900 built
9351 S Catalpa Avenue
For Sale
$695,000

9351 S Catalpa Avenue

Newaygo, MI 49337

6 bd 2.5 ba 3076 sqft 1972 built
1360 E Bigelow Creek Trail
For Sale
$399,900

1360 E Bigelow Creek Trail

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 2127 sqft 1960 built
250 E 88th Street
For Sale
$299,000

250 E 88th Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 1.5 ba 2468 sqft 1968 built
5708 E 52nd Street
For Sale
$475,000

5708 E 52nd Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

2 bd 1 ba 960 sqft 1970 built
5539 Front Street
For Sale
$285,000

5539 Front Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

1 bd 1 ba 898 sqft 1940 built
5109 E Manitou Way
For Sale
$1,395,000

5109 E Manitou Way

Newaygo, MI 49337

4 bd 3 ba 3299 sqft 2022 built
4733 Chestnut Avenue
For Sale
$365,000

4733 Chestnut Avenue

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 1387 sqft 2024 built
5550 Cozy Point Drive
For Sale
$629,000

5550 Cozy Point Drive

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2.5 ba 1550 sqft 2005 built
217 John Street
For Sale
$219,900

217 John Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 3 ba 2302 sqft 1900 built
5904 E Division Street
For Sale
$634,999

5904 E Division Street

Newaygo, MI 49337

4 bd 3.5 ba 3778 sqft 2019 built
3696 S Locust Avenue
For Sale
$219,000

3696 S Locust Avenue

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 1 ba 1200 sqft 1985 built
4468 Teal Lane
For Sale
$235,000

4468 Teal Lane

Newaygo, MI 49337

3 bd 2 ba 1300 sqft 1969 built
42
Nearby Cities
All Cities
  • Grant7.7 mi34 Listings
  • White Cloud10 mi85 Listings
  • Fremont12 mi65 Listings
  • Howard City12 mi64 Listings
  • Pierson12 mi24 Listings
  • Kent City14 mi25 Listings
  • Sand Lake14 mi22 Listings
  • Morley14 mi25 Listings
  • Cedar Springs17 mi94 Listings
  • Bailey13 mi2 Listings
  • Casnovia14 mi8 Listings
  • Sparta18 mi59 Listings
Similar Searches
  • For Sale in Newaygo
  • Rentals in Newaygo
  • Houses in Newaygo
  • Condos & Apartments in Newaygo
  • Townhouses & Duplexes in Newaygo
  • Lots & Land in Newaygo
  • Farms & Ranches in Newaygo
Featured Areas
All Areas
  • Ottawa County4259 Listings
  • Allegan County2767 Listings
  • Grand Rapids2302 Listings
  • Holland567 Listings
  • Allendale292 Listings
  • South Haven266 Listings
  • Grandville249 Listings
  • Jenison215 Listings
  • West Olive155 Listings
  • Saugatuck153 Listings
Featured Searches
Advanced Search
  • $200k to $300k Homes
  • $300k to $400k Homes
  • $400k to $500k Homes
  • Acreage
  • Commercial Properties
  • Farms & Ranches
  • Golf Course Homes
  • Homes Listed this Week
  • Homes with 2+ Beds
  • Homes with Pools
  • Large Houses (2k+ sqft)
  • Luxury Condos ($400k+)
  • Multi-Family Homes
  • New Construction
  • Oceanfront Condos
  • Rentals Under $2k
  • Rentals with Pets
  • Under $200k Homes
  • Under $250k Homes
  • Water View Homes
  • Water View Homes
Popular Cities
All Cities
  • Grand Rapids933 Listings
  • Kalamazoo683 Listings
  • Muskegon593 Listings
  • Battle Creek587 Listings
  • Jackson532 Listings
  • Ann Arbor467 Listings
  • Detroit387 Listings
  • Holland379 Listings
  • Niles238 Listings
  • St. Joseph208 Listings
Popular Subdivisions
All Subdivisions
  • Grande Estates3 Listings
  • Woodland Estates3 Listings
  • Shady Oaks2 Listings
  • Sunset Point1 Listings
  • Fairways1 Listings
  • Winding Creek1 Listings
  • Sunflower Ridge1 Listings
Popular Zip Codes
All Zips
  • Homes in 4822439 Listings
  • Homes in 484395 Listings
  • Homes in 49201248 Listings
  • Homes in 4822842 Listings
  • Homes in 49441233 Listings
  • Homes in 4822737 Listings
  • Homes in 4821930 Listings
  • Homes in 49120238 Listings
  • Homes in 4884320 Listings
  • Homes in 4823517 Listings
Recent Articles
All Articles
  • Maximizing Property Value: Expert Tips for Grand Haven, Michigan Homeowners
  • Gavin Steenwyk: Your Top Choice for Finding the Best Realtor in Grand Haven, Michigan
  • Unlocking the Potential of Acreage in Grand Haven, Michigan
  • Lakefront Property in Grand Haven, Michigan: Your Ultimate Guide
  • 7 Proven Strategies to Increase Property Value in Zeeland, Michigan
  • Unlocking the Secrets to Finding the Best Realtor in Zeeland, Michigan
  • Discover the Best Acreage Options in Zeeland, Michigan
  • Lakefront Property in Zeeland, Michigan: A Hidden Gem for Homebuyers
  • Strategic Approaches to Boost Your Holland, Michigan Property Value
  • The Ultimate Guide to Finding the Best Realtor in Holland, Michigan

City Guide

About Newaygo

Real Estate & Housing

Neighborhoods

Lifestyle in Newaygo

Schools & Education

Getting Around

Parks & Recreation

About Newaygo

Frequently asked questions

Where do we start?

Start with mortgage pre-approval — it tells you what you can spend before you fall in love with a home. From there, we'll help you find neighborhoods that fit how you actually live, and walk you through every step of the purchase.

How long does it take to sell?

Timelines depend on the market, your price, and your home's condition. Right now, most well-priced homes sell in 30 to 60 days. We'll put together a plan that makes your property stand out and gets it in front of serious buyers.

What costs should I anticipate?

Buyers usually pay closing costs — lender fees, title insurance, inspections — roughly 2 to 5 percent of the purchase price. Sellers handle agent commissions and any repairs you agree to. We walk through every cost up front, so there are no surprises at closing.

Should I buy or sell first?

It depends on your finances and what the market looks like. Bridge loans and contingent offers each work in different situations. We'll talk through the trade-offs so you can move forward with a plan that makes sense for you.

Why work with us?

We know these neighborhoods because we live here. Every agent on our team works in the community they serve, so the advice you get goes deeper than what a spreadsheet can tell you. We use technology to keep things clear and simple. The result? A smooth experience from your first search to the day you get the keys.

Still have questions about Newaygo?

Get in touch
  • Local Guide
  • Cities

Explore the area

Nearby cities

Bailey, MI2 homes for saleMedian$293,000−21.8%Days on market8Per sq ft$199
Casnovia, MI8 homes for saleMedian$255,000+3.6%Days on market3Per sq ft$175
Cedar Springs, MI94 homes for saleMedian$350,000−1.3%Days on market15Per sq ft$211
Fremont, MI65 homes for saleMedian$275,000+1.0%Days on market68Per sq ft$177
Grant, MI34 homes for saleMedian$340,000+36.0%Days on market33Per sq ft$187
Howard City, MI64 homes for saleMedian$345,000+27.8%Days on market31Per sq ft$219
Kent City, MI25 homes for saleMedian$349,950+2.2%Days on market16Per sq ft$175
Morley, MI25 homes for saleMedian$247,500−21.4%Days on market90Per sq ft$172
Pierson, MI24 homes for saleMedian$424,900−3.4%Days on market37Per sq ft$238
Sand Lake, MI22 homes for saleMedian$355,000+10.9%Days on market20Per sq ft$264
Sparta, MI59 homes for saleMedian$371,565+6.1%Days on market21Per sq ft$216
White Cloud, MI85 homes for saleMedian$265,000+52.5%Days on market24Per sq ft$214
12